year 3, Issue 2 (Fall & Winter 2018)
CIAUJ 2018, 3(2): 47-61 |
Back to browse issues page
Download citation:
BibTeX | RIS | EndNote | Medlars | ProCite | Reference Manager | RefWorks
Send citation to:
BibTeX | RIS | EndNote | Medlars | ProCite | Reference Manager | RefWorks
Send citation to:
Mir Gholmai M, Kaynejad M A, Alizadeh B. An Appraisal of the Tabriz Comprehensive Plan in terms of the Feasibility of Islamic Justice. CIAUJ 2018; 3 (2) :47-61
URL: http://ciauj-tabriziau.ir/article-1-157-en.html
URL: http://ciauj-tabriziau.ir/article-1-157-en.html
1- Faculty of Architecture and Urbanism, Tabriz Islamic Art University, Tabriz, Iran , m.mirgholami@tabriziau.ac.ir
2- Civil Engineering Faculty, Sahand University of Technology, Tabriz, Iran
3- Faculty of Architecture and Urbanism, Tabriz Islamic Art University, Tabriz, Iran
2- Civil Engineering Faculty, Sahand University of Technology, Tabriz, Iran
3- Faculty of Architecture and Urbanism, Tabriz Islamic Art University, Tabriz, Iran
Abstract: (4105 Views)
The dominance of the capitalist system on the structures and processes of the urban planning system has led urban development patterns toward generating income. The prevalence of such this pattern has created a conflict between private and public interests. Attempt to resolve this conflict has led urban planning to the concept of spatial justice; so that spatial justice in urban planning has been defined as thinking about how to resolve conflicts between the public and private interests in the city. However, due to the dependence of the concept of spatial justice on worldview, it would be impossible to provide a universal framework, nowlly. The concept of spatial justice in view of leftist urban planners towards claiming of right and the rightist urban planners towards civil liberties has moved. Therefore, it seems that the presentation of a conceptual and practical framework based on Islamic worldview is necessary. This research is a developmental and fundamental research. It, on the one hand, seeks to explain a theoretical-operational framework of spatial justice in the Islamic city and, on the other hand, it seeks to assess spatial justice position in the structure and process of the urban planning system of Iran in general and the comprehensive plan document of Tabriz city in particular. In this research to the assessment of spatial justice position in the content of the comprehensive plan document of Tabriz city (Approved 1395) has been addressed.
The methodology of research has been at explaining stage of the theoretical-operational framework, the rational reasoning method; in the stage of documents content analysis, the discourse analysis method with emphasis on De Saussure semiotics and an assessment stage, balanced scorecard method.
The most important finding of this research is the development of an analytical framework for assessing the spatial justice in urban development plans; framework that its intellectual foundation is based on Islamic worldview. This study shows that spatial justice in the Islamic city can be defined and evaluated through four criteria: "self-regulation", "the right to the city", "empowerment" and "spatial equilibrium".
The self-regulation means active control of residents on urban development; the right of the people to the city means the equal right of all from right to urban life as a rich culture and diverse cultural environment without any discrimination (gender, age, health status, Income, nationality, race, immigration status or political and religious orientations); the empowerment means development of human-environmental capabilities and, finally, The spatial equilibrium has been defined in terms of the elimination of the disappearance of the layers of spatial poverty on human poverty. The evaluation of the content of the comprehensive plan of Tabriz city showed that the plan has been seek spatial justice through efficient and optimal use of land. Such view of the realization of spatial justice in the city, more than political, legal and social is a physical and economic view; and it can pave way for abuses of the private sector.
The methodology of research has been at explaining stage of the theoretical-operational framework, the rational reasoning method; in the stage of documents content analysis, the discourse analysis method with emphasis on De Saussure semiotics and an assessment stage, balanced scorecard method.
The most important finding of this research is the development of an analytical framework for assessing the spatial justice in urban development plans; framework that its intellectual foundation is based on Islamic worldview. This study shows that spatial justice in the Islamic city can be defined and evaluated through four criteria: "self-regulation", "the right to the city", "empowerment" and "spatial equilibrium".
The self-regulation means active control of residents on urban development; the right of the people to the city means the equal right of all from right to urban life as a rich culture and diverse cultural environment without any discrimination (gender, age, health status, Income, nationality, race, immigration status or political and religious orientations); the empowerment means development of human-environmental capabilities and, finally, The spatial equilibrium has been defined in terms of the elimination of the disappearance of the layers of spatial poverty on human poverty. The evaluation of the content of the comprehensive plan of Tabriz city showed that the plan has been seek spatial justice through efficient and optimal use of land. Such view of the realization of spatial justice in the city, more than political, legal and social is a physical and economic view; and it can pave way for abuses of the private sector.
Keywords: Islamic justice, spatial justice, justice-oriented urban planning, Tabriz Comprehensive Plan.
Type of Study: Original Article |
Subject:
Culture & lifestyle
Received: 2018/05/30 | Accepted: 2018/05/30 | ePublished: 2018/05/30
Received: 2018/05/30 | Accepted: 2018/05/30 | ePublished: 2018/05/30
References
1. Aminzadeh, B. and M. Naghizadeh. 2002. Islamic utopia: City of justice. Soffeh 12(3-4): 21‒31 [in Persian].
2. Bahrampour, Shaban Ali. 2000. Introduction to critical discourse analysis. Tehran: Media Studies and Researches center [in Persian].
3. Campbell, Scott and Susan S. Fainstein .2003. Readings in planning Theory. New Jersy: Wiley-Blackwell.
4. Campbell, H. and R. Marshall. 2006. Towards justice in planning. European Planning Studies Press 14 (2): 239–52. [DOI:10.1080/09654310500418192]
5. Dadashpour, Hashem, Bahram Alizadeh and Faramarz Rostami. 2016. Spatial justice discourse in the city. Tehran: Azarakhsh publications [in Persian].
6. Dufaux, Frederic and Pascale Philifert. 2013. Spatial Justice and Territorial Policies. Paris: West Paris University Press.
7. Fainstein, Susan.2010. The just city. New York: Cornell University Press.
8. Farabi, Abu naser .1961. Al-Fusul al-Madina. Translated by D. M. Dunlop. Cambridge: University of Combridge Press.
9. Gervais-Lambony, Philippe. 2014. Spatial Justice and city. Paris: Karthala Press.
10. Harvey, David. 1990. Social Justice and the City. Georgia: University of Georgia Press.
11. –––––––. 2008. The right to the city. New Left Review 53: 23–40.
12. –––––––. 1973. Social Justice and the City. Georgia: University of Georgia Press.
13. –––––––. 1996. On Planning the Ideology of Planning: Reading in planning theory. Edited by Scott Campbell and Susan Fainstein. New Jersy: Blackwell Publishers.
14. Ibn Rushd and Abu al-Walid. 1956. Averroes Commentary on Plato`s Republic. Edited by E.I.J. Rosenthal. Cambridge: University of Cambridge Press.
15. Ibn Sina and Abu Ali al-Husayn. 1960. Kitab Al-Shafa: Al-Ilahiyat. Edited by Yusuf Musa and Sulayman Dunya. East: Cairo press [in Arabic].
16. Khadduri, Majid. 2002. The Islamic Conception of Justice. Translated by Mostafa Younesi and Mohammad Zahiri. 2015. Tehran: University of Mofid publications [in Persian].
17. Kheyroddin, R. 2014. Reviewing Physical Incarnation of Islamic Concept of Spatial Justice Cartographic Analysis of Spatial Justice in 112 Districts of Tehran Metropolis. Journal of Research in Islamic Architecture 1: 43- 57 [in Persian].
18. Lefebvre, Henry. 2000. The right to the city. Architecture Culture. New York: Rizzoli.
19. Marcuse, Peter. 2009. Spatial Justice: Derivative but Causal of Social Injustice. Columbia: University of Columbia Press.
20. Mirfakhraei, Tezha. 2004. The process of discourse analysis. Tehran: Ministry of Culture and Islamic Guidance publications [in Persian].
21. Mirjany, H. 2010. Logical reasoning as a research method. Soffeh 50: 35‒50 [in Persian].
22. Motahhari, Morteza. 1989. Twenty speeches. Tehran: Sadra publications [in Persian].
23. –––––––. 1997. Justice of God. Tehran: Sadra publications [in Persian].
24. Naghsh Mohit engineering consultant. 2011. Development and construction plan of Tabriz city [in Persian].
25. Qutb, Sayyid. Social justice in Islam. 1953. Translated by Mohammad A. Gerami and Hadi Khosroshahi. 2000. Tehran: Kolbeh Shorouq publications [in Persian].
26. Sadr, Muhammad Baqir. 1960. Our economics. Translated by Mohammad Mehdi Fouladvand. 1981. Tehran: Islamic Sciences Foundation [in Persian].
27. Sedigh Sarvestani, R. A. and A. Daqagheleh. 2008. Comparing the attitudes of ordinary citizens and community elites about social justice. Social sciences 24‒47 [in Persian].
28. Saeidi Rezvani, H. 2014. Passing on a fair city in theories of urbanization and Islamic teachings. Sustainable city 1(1). 135‒63 [in Persian].
29. Shokouhi Bidhendi, M. S. 2015a. Evaluating Spatial Justice in Urban Development Plans, PhD Diss. Urbanism faculty. Collage of fine arts. University of Tehran [in Persian].
30. –––––––. 2015b. Evolution of the concept of justice in the Indian society and its spatial representation. Journal of art and civilization of the orient 2(6). 30‒41 [in Persian].
31. Soja, Edward .2010. Seeking Spatial Justice. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
32. Tabatabaei, Mohammad Hossein. 2014. Al-Meizan fi Tafsire Al-Quran. Qom: Esmaeilian press office [in Persian].
33. Yagoubi, Daryoush. 2009. Iranians understanding of Justice. Tehran: Jame-e-shenasan publications [in Persian].
Send email to the article author
| Rights and permissions | |
 |
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License. |
