Amir H. Zekrgoo,
Volume 1, Issue 1 (12-2015)
Abstract
Eclecticism, the subject of this paper, manifests when elements from different structural, spatial and decorative forms and styles, carrying features representing specific and distinct cultures combine in a single work, chiefly in architecture. The term ‘eclecticism’, however, in the mindset and literature of societies with ancient artistic heritage, is imbued with negative denotations. This is because “artistic styles” in such societies are often associated with “identity” and “originality”, both of whom designate a long progress in the passage of time, while eclecticism appears to lack such “valuable” process.
In the process of deliberating eclecticism a few questions seem fundamentally relevant: How can then we define “identity” and “style” in the art and architecture of younger societies? Is modern religious architecture “without identity” if it does not follow the traditional trend? To what degree can architects incorporate imported alien elements in designing of local religious buildings? And finally, can eclectic architecture reach the status of a proper “architectural style”?
Eclecticism gained rapid momentum in the field of Malaysian mosque architecture during the past two decades. Significant eclectic mosques that have transformed the scene and skylines of major Malaysian cities have often been heavily financed by the government – an indication of conscious choice of direction. The subject is yet to be studied and deserves a systematic research. This paper aims to present an analytical study of the concept of ‘eclecticism’ and ‘identity’ in the context of Malaysian contemporary mosque architecture.
Massud Wahdattalab, Elham Rezaiezadeh,
Volume 2, Issue 1 (7-2016)
Abstract
Using domes to cover large gaps has a long history in Iran. Lack of solid and long woods, which indeed are the main elements of the flat coverage, has introduced vaults and domes as the popular options for coverage purposes. In Iranian architecture, domes enjoy a considerable position. The Iranian Muslim architect has used his talent and taste, as best as possible, to build mosques, as not only structural considerations have been considered in his works, but also the aesthetic aspects of domes have been dealt with.
This study tries to analyze the gradual evolution of mosques' domes during different historical epochs by emphasizing the dimensional proportions of domes, as an aesthetic component. It also answers the question that is there any significant relationship between aesthetic components of domes during different historical eras and in a single geographical area? For this purpose, initially the available related literature was reviewed to compile typology styles and to elicit effective components in order to compare and classify domes. Limiting these studies to the Central Iranian Plateau helped us to control our study's range. Methods and documents used in this study were sections of domes of mosques and the mentioned geography regarding the bibliographical references. Achievements of this study were organized using descriptive-analytical methods, depicting scatter diagrams and analysis of statistical data. This study showed that the external deflection of mosques' dome has been increased by Mozzaffari-Teymurid, whereas it started to decrease during Safavid era. Unlike the external deflection, the internal proportions in mono-shell and double-shell domes had overlap with each other and there are not very different. At the same, the historical evolution of form of Iranian mosques' domes follows Khagi, Nar and shamrock domes.
Mr Mehdi Mohammadzadeh, Ms Maryam Mesineh Asl,
Volume 2, Issue 2 (3-2017)
Abstract
Regarding to a special respect to humans and their living environment, the Harat school has used plethora of architectural elements. Architecture in the Harat school is an element spread in the space of miniature in order to arrange the structure and to create an appropriate position for the characters of miniature. In the present study development of architectural elements and their influence on the structure of the artworks has been investigated using an expression-analytic method. The effect of architectural elements have never been constant through the history starting with a bare facing of a building and improving gradually to an evolutionary state in miniatures of the Harat school which has converted to an alive and dynamic space affecting the entire structure of the composition as included in this study. The experimental species of the current study have been selected from the artworks of primitive and late eras of timured miniatures. A particular perspective thanks to the architectural elements along with frequently changing the point of view and simultaneous illustration of several spaces of a building are the main charachteristics of timured miniatures. Buildings demonstrated in timured miniatures include a vast spectrum from religious buildings such as mosques to civil ones like martial constructions and bathhouses.
Neda Naseri, Kourosh Momeni, Mohammad Amir Kakizadeh, Behzad Vasiq,
Volume 2, Issue 2 (3-2017)
Abstract
Privacy is one of the basic principles of Islamic architecture. Islamic texts like Quran and Hadiths indicate that privacy is an important subject in the house which provides peace for the family. The houses that are built in Islamic era represent this principle, but unfortunately, this important architectural principle is nowadays ignored in houses. Therefore, reviewing the privacy principle in the traditional houses can help the architects recognize and apply it in houses. The entrance hierarchy, which is based on several factors such as religious, cultural, social, etc., is one of the elements to create the privacy in houses. It seems that this hierarchy in Bushehr’s houses is due to other factors that have not been investigated before. This article tries to discuss these points: the meaning of privacy hierarchy, reviewing the privacy hierarchy in the entrance of Bushehr historical houses, and its relation with the homeowner’s job. So in this article, the theory of hierarchy of privacy in Islam has been used by library resources, articles and internet sites and the traditional houses of Bushehr are studied by using interviews with experts, direct observation, and the documents that have remained from these houses. The results show that the occupation of Muslim home owners of Bushehr has influenced the entrance hierarchy in buildings. So the houses of important governmental people had the highest hierarchy privacy due to their relations with important people. Doctors and businessmen’s homes had a relatively high level of privacy due to their relations with customers and ordinary people. The homes of people with office jobs and normal social level had the lowest hierarchy privacy among the homes that were surveyed. Thus it can be said that, based on a Muslim owner’s job, the amount of privacy hierarchy had been different which are classified into three different types. The first type; the entrance was located at the corner of the house plan as of the businessmen and doctors’ houses. Due to a high number of visiting people, the entrance was designed with high privacy level and no direct visibility into the house. In some cases, for men’s trade affairs, there was a room whose entrance was located in the first vestibule of the house.The second type; the entrance of these houses was located on one side of the house plan. It opened to the courtyard with less hierarchy than the previous type. It just contained a corridor because few unfamiliar people visited these houses which belonged to the governmental office workers. The third type; these houses had two separate entrances and belonged to important people (such as consuls, mayors, sheriffs, etc.). The house and office of these people were combined in one complex. Because important governmental people visited these houses, two entrances were created to separate the private and public sections of the house.
Ahad Nejad Ebrahimi, Minou Gharebaglou, Amir Hossein Farshchian,
Volume 2, Issue 2 (3-2017)
Abstract
In its conceptual meaning, Social Interaction, as a mean of connecting individuals in a society, is defined differently in the realm of Sociology. In this respect, the effective status of social interactions in the formation of proper social relations is shown in Architecture. The benefits of this status include cooperation to achieve active-public profit and its results, the development of participation, trust and cohesion in the society, and the improvement of relations between people and groups. Social interaction in western notion is bound to public places in the society, the reason why public places such as streets, recreation centers, and other urban architectures are paid a lot of attention. The definition of social interaction in western architecture is in line with an urban public place which has resulted in different attitudes in the formation and architecture of such places, compared to Islamic thought.
The principles of designing social interaction places in architecture apply to issues like the formation of the place, the values which complement the lives of people in Islamic cities and the special functional-behavioral codes that assess the degree of success in consensus around Islamic thought. The understanding of values and concepts derived from Islamic thought in order to achieve a basic understanding which, in the end, leads to action is among the principles of social interaction place in Islamic thought. First the values are introduced to and accepted by the society. Then, these values are assessed on the basis of religious codes that are spread in communities, and, finally, converted into behaviour on the part of the people. Western thought focuses on social interaction in a larger layer of the society that is social spaces and, to achieve this, tries to attract people to such spaces. A proper social interaction in this doctrine is the result of the congregation of people in public urban spaces.
Islam introduces the family as the first and most important basis for the formation of social interaction, where this interaction starts from individual members of the family and gradually spreads towards the society. Notions such as Axiology, Ethology, family events, special spaces for the elderly, the adjacency of the main space with semi-private spaces, guest issues, and other principles of social interaction spaces are evident in Islamic society. In a hierarchically complementing fashion, these principles stabilize the process of interaction in Islamic society through special social procedures. The architectural place of a Muslim architect attempts to reach Islamic values in social interactions and solid relationships of the people in the society. Islamic city shelters its members by a constructive and pleasant concept called social interactions.
Yahya Nourian, Mohammad Hossein Kasraei,
Volume 2, Issue 2 (3-2017)
Abstract
Islamic Greh (Knot) is known as one of the significant geometric patterns in Islamic art and architecture. Because of the complexity of drawing, Greh is considered a prominent and complicated technique and an unknown subject in both artists and orientalist’s points of view. Grehs have been used as decoration in Islamic cultures for over a thousand years, yet have not still lost their attractiveness. Aside from its beauty, many historians and architects are interested in finding the mathematical and geometrical aspects of Greh. Regardless of some old books and documents which introduce the methods of drawing of Greh, many contemporary western researchers have attempted to reinvent their own new methods for drawing Greh. These new methods lead to establish a novel comprehensive insight to understand, draw and use Greh, presenting different results in comparison to traditional methods. The main concern of this paper is to enlighten the differences between traditional and modern methods, based on their applications. These differences could be distinguished well by looking at examples such as those Grehs that are embedded on a curved surface.
In this paper, we provide a comparison between traditional and contemporary methods for drawing Grehs. This comparison reveals that the main feature of traditional method is drawing Grehs according to the geometry of the surface on which they are embedded. This notion is called Chand-Zaminegi in Persian that could be explained by introducing Dast-Gardan Grehs which are impossible to be drawn via modern methods. Unlike common Grehs –which are drawn based on an interactive basic unit- Dast-Gardan is constructed according to the form and shape of the surface, so the measurement and shape of the surface alter the process of its design. Dast-Gardan patterns have been used to materialize the geometric order on a complicated surface like a curved-surface. If Greh is designed and produced by considering Chand-Zaminegi approach, it could be the extension of the traditional method.
This paper consists of six main sections. The first section is an introduction and the second one presents a comprehensive definition of Greh based on documents, books and also lessons taught by some Iranian professional artisans who inherited their profession from their ancestors. The third section introduces the various traditional methods for drawing Greh. This section also describes a sample which shows step-by-step procedures for generating a typical Greh by traditional approaches. The fourth Section studies modern drawing methods and categorizes all contemporary efforts in seven types. The fifth section is allocated to explain the distinction between traditional and modern methods. For these purposes, some traditional terms like Chand-Zaminegi and Dast-Gardan patterns are introduced. The paper provides a conclusion in section six by explaining the results and suggesting some opportunities for future work
Dr Habib Shahbazi Shiran, Phd Student Mehdi Hosani Niya, Phd Student Mehdi Kazempour,
Volume 3, Issue 1 (9-2017)
Abstract
Blue Mosque is one of the works by Abul Mozaffar Jahanshah bin Qara Yousef, a member of Qaraqoyounlu tribe, in Tabriz. It was completed in 870 AH under Jan Beigum Khatoon's supervision (Jahanshah's wife).This mosque consists of diverse patterns including herbal and geometric ones as well as various epigraphs. Epigraphs which are mostly recorded by Kufic and Thulth scripts are in accordance with adjacent patterns to show moderation and harmony. The main objective of this research was to determine the effect of Mysticism and Sufism, including Hurufiye faction on epigraphs' content. The method employed in this paper was both descriptive and analytical. In line with this, data were collected through library research method and visiting the monument. Research findings showed that the greatest diversity of colors are specified to azure blue in epigraphs and white in epigraphs' script which are symbolic in community of the mystics. Moreover, sun and star patterns as well as Arabic logion are clearly revealed the impact of Mysticism and Sufism in creating ornaments of this great building during Qaraqoyounlu's age. Last but not the least, this paper showed that religious evolutions such as the existence of Hurufiye faction's beliefs along with Mysticism and Sufism had significant impact on the formation of patterns and epigraphs' contents of the building.
Ahad Nejad Ebrahimi, Yaser Shahbazi, Amir Amjad Mohammadi,
Volume 3, Issue 1 (9-2017)
Abstract
The so-called “Karbandi” and “Rasmibandi” are two kinds of vault covering elements based on Islamic star geometry, which are of the most common patterns in the restored projects and new buildings, including the Haj Mohammad Qoli Timche in Tabriz historic bazaar, the Mausoleum of Omar Khayyam in Nishapur, and others. These patterns are created by intersecting several rib vaults based on totally strict mathematical and structural techniques. Despite the importance of Karbandi and Rasmibandi in Persian architecture, there are plethora of contradictions and disagreements between workmen and researchers for determining and classification of various types of Karbandi and Rasmibandi. Therefore, the solidarity of previous statements and papers are diminished. Accordingly, the major question is as: what are the differences between various types of Karbandi and Rasmibandi based on their place and method of usage. The purpose of this paper is the clarification of Karbandi and Rasmibandi types and to find the similarities and differences between them. This study is a basic theoretical research and the research methodology used is analytic-descriptive, which relies on historical sources, historical documents, texts and images in historical periods and constructed samples. The paper is presented in two major sections. The first section is related to the scrutiny and comparison of previous works and attempts to determine the specific definitions of Karbandi and Rasmibandi concepts. As a consequence, the position of Kars in either major or secondary vaults cannot be used as criteria to distinguish Karbandi from Rasmibandi. The Karbandi as coverture can be used in both covertures of major vaults and coverture of secondary vaults, whilst, Rasmibandi can exclusively be used beneath major vaults. The most important difference between the major and secondary vaults is the kind of their load bearing mechanism. In the case of major vaults, the burden of both two clusters, dead loads and live loads, is by means of Karbandi. However, in the secondary vaults, Karbandi usually bears its own dead loads. Moreover, the Nimkar (semi-work) can be categorized in two Karbandi and Rasmibandi groups based on their performance and load bearing behavior. Karbandi has a rib vault of load bearings elements, whilst, Rasmibandi is constructed in dependence with upper vaults.
In the second section of this paper, the applications of different Karbandi and Rasmibandi types are investigated and their key points are highlighted by considering the findings of the previous section. The results indicate that, not only can Karbandi be used in the applications of coverture positions, but it also has non-coverture uses. Karbandi is someties used as either “Chapireh-Sazi” or in facade of buildings. In the case of “Chapireh-Sazi”, Karbandi is usually used by means of “Shekanj” and “Gosheh-Sazi”. In the case of Gosheh-Sazi, the transition is usually done without any height increase of dome. Thus, “Chanbare” is not created beneath the dome and the height of Chapireh-Sazi remains unchanged. Finally, a comprehensive classification of various types of Karbandi and Rasmibandi was presented based on usage place, constructional and form-related features, application, structural function, and material of rib vaults.
Gholamhossein Memariyan, Abbas Ghaffari, Farzaneh Gholizadeh,
Volume 3, Issue 1 (9-2017)
Abstract
In addition to their ritual function and sublime terrestrial status, Mosques play an important role in systemizing the various aspects of human life and activities. Mosques need an appropriate space to meet the needs of the users. Although the spiritual benefit of mankind from mosques is highly realized, minimum architectural requirements are necessary to facilitate his/her spiritual excellence. So a set of architectural requirements of a mosque such as a right layout, a true function, an appropriate form and decoration, as well as its natural structure seems necessary to be defined. Tabriz is one of the oldest cities in Iran and has many historical mosques within its urban structure, most of which are located at Tabriz Bazar and, due to a great number of people attending these mosques for praying and other spiritual activities, they are considered as the most successful examples. The reason for this, it seems, lies at their structures, along with other conceptual parameters. Therefore, a comprehensive study of the architectural aspects of these historical mosques can be of utmost importance. One of the advantages of the typological study of buildings is the identification of the architectural strengths and weaknesses of the samples in order to arrive at a deeper understanding and evaluation of their structure. So, based on a field study, the present research attempts to extract the typological parameters of more than 40 historical mosques in Tabriz by implementing Delphi tools. In so doing, first the samples are analyzed based on the users’ behaviors and then, according to features like internal space and configuration, architectural structure, decorations, materials, light, entry manner and relation with the environment, the typological parameters are investigated. The findings of this study can provide a comprehensive understanding of the historical mosques in Tabriz and build a basis for their topological as well as paleontological categorization.
Sanaz Jafarpour Nasser,
Volume 3, Issue 1 (9-2017)
Abstract
With the arrival of Shah Ismail I (1513-1551 A.D) to Tabriz and his coronation at Sahib-Abad government house, the Safavid dynasty was established in 907 AH / 1502 AD. The city of Tabriz, as the first capital of the Safavids, has had an elaborate spatial organization since the Turkmen period (Qaraqvinlu and Aghqvinlu). What impressed the nature of such a structure was how the old city center was linked with the new governmental city center. The design of a new governmental Arsan (complex) in Qazvin (962 AH) and Isfahan (1006 AH) as the next capital of the Safavids was influenced by this structure.
In the city of Tabriz, the Atiq Square as an old urban space was connected to Sahib Abad Square as the new government city square via commercial spaces such as Bazaars and Qeysaries. With changes in the hierarchy of the communication elements, this system can also be tracked in the Second Safavid capital of Qazvin, in the garden complex of Jafarabad Garden, Saadat Abad Square, and the new market complex and street.
But the milestone of this developmental trend took place in the urbanization of the Isfahan school in Isfahan as the third Safavid capital. The present research attempts to answer the questions related to the spatial organization of Tabriz during the Turkmen period, and how the urban elements in the form of a communication system in the Safavid capitals was used. The objective of this study is to investigate the effect of the pattern of the spatial organization formed during the Turkmen period in Tabriz on Safavid urbanization in terms of the communication between the old and the new city centers.
In order to explain the objectives of our research, a comparative study was carried out between the Safavid structure in three cities of Tabriz, Qazvin and Isfahan. The data were compiled and interpreted using the qualitative content analysis method. Finally, with the comparative analysis of the cases, it has been concluded that the pattern of commercial and public spaces in the form of a bazaar complex to link the old town center with the new government center has been a successful factor in creating a coherent urban structure.
Samira Rahimi Atani, Kaveh Bazrafakan, Iman Raeisi,
Volume 4, Issue 1 (9-2018)
Abstract
One of the major challenges in the field of architecture is the reading and critiquing individual works regardless of relevant textual layers that may affect the formation of the work. The main concern of the present research is the great importance of criticism to the architectural community. Unfortunately however, the lack of systematic readings of architectural works has led to the absence of reliable criticisms that may help improve the quality of the works. As one of the most widely used concepts in contemporary literary criticism, intertextuality refers to the idea that a text is interconnected with earlier and later texts; therefore, every text should be read and appreciated in relation to other texts. As a concept, intertextuality is not exclusive to literary arts. It is also relevant to other artistic subjects including cinema, painting, music, architecture, photography and, in general, all forms of cultural or artistic production. Intertextuality has grown out of the field of literary criticism and has been put to use in reading and critiquing other artistic texts as well. In this study, we intend to read architectural works through an application of the theory of intertextuality to the field of architectural criticism. By relying on an intertextual reading, this study addresses the relations between peritext and intertext elements and their impact on the formation of the overall meaning of architectural works. We have formulated the Intertextuality Reading Model for the intertextual reading of architecture based on the theory of intertextuality and have evaluated the model by applying it to our reading of Al-Qadir Mosque as a case study. The question that we, herein, seek to answer is: How do we read architectural works based on the Intertextuality Reading Model? This study uses a qualitative design. Data collection was conducted via descriptive procedures and content analysis was carried out via discursive procedures, i.e., logical arguments. The study focuses on the theory of intertextuality and addresses the different layers of the text, i.e., the architecture work, in light of syntagmatic and paradigmatic axes, diachronic and synchronic approaches, codification and implications. Our findings indicate that the use of an intertextual method prevents superficial readings of architectural works, facilitates the understanding of hidden layers of meaning and activates broader paradigms of interpretation. The different semantic aspects of an architectural work in intertextual relations can be uncovered by a plurality of different layers at the vertical (“diachronic”) axis of its semiotic system and the horizontal (“synchronic”) axis of its codification system.
Salman Noghrehkar, Fatemeh Zarei Hajiabadi, Fatemeh Mohammad-Ganji, Ahmad Danaeinia,
Volume 4, Issue 1 (9-2018)
Abstract
Understanding the invaluable history of Iranian architecture and utilizing its sustainable bases, principles and patterns can help us improve architecture both in the present and in the future. To understand Iranian architecture, it is essential that we can read it thoroughly and correctly; but before that, we need to have a comprehensive definition of it. So, the main question of this research is: How should we read Iranian architecture? And that question gives rise to two more questions: What is Iranian architecture? And why should we read it? To answer these questions, we first surveyed experts (in two groups: researchers and designers) for their viewpoints on Iranian architecture. The collected data were analyzed, categorized and codified in three groups: the definition, the necessity and the method of reading architecture. The findings are presented below as based on the three research questions: What is Iranian architecture? The resulting data were coded into five categories: architect, goal, material, form and context. In this step, based on the codes, we adapted Aristotle’s theory of the “four causes of being” to develop a conceptual model of architecture including its four causes (material, formal, efficient and final) and its different types of contexts (natural, social and formal/physical). This model is aimed at finding an answer to the question “What is Iranian architecture?” and serves as a framework for the other two questions. Why should we read the history of Iranian architecture? The collected data about the necessity of reading architecture were coded into three categories: extracting the principles, exploring the patterns and utilizing those principles and patterns in contemporary architecture. How should we read Iranian architecture? By answering the previous two questions, we have approached the answer to the third question. Identifying the goals of reading and the relevant factors will guide us in reading architecture. To reach a practical method for reading architecture, we have drawn on our experiences in teaching university courses in architectural history as well as student activities. We will propose a five-stage reading process (description, analysis, criticism, instruction and practice) and three stages of reading (before, during and after visiting a building). Finally, we will present a checklist of the necessary activities for reading Iranian architecture and lay out the results of using the proposed reading method in five areas of architecture including education, research, production, media and policy-making.
Mohammad Javad Abbaszadeh, Bahador Zamani,
Volume 5, Issue 1 (6-2020)
Abstract
The mosques as the principal representative of the physical structures of Islamic architecture have once been a clear demonstration of the crystallization of sacred space in the human-built environment, while today, unfortunately, due to intolerance and neglect, often their key and vital quality is lost in purely physical form. The purpose of this study is to recognize the concept of sacred space and evaluate its criteria in several contemporary mosques seeking to answer the question of how and to what extent the criteria of sacred space concept are presented in contemporary mosques. The method of this research is descriptive-evaluation and its data collection is based on the study of library resources, observation, and content analysis. Regarding the experience of the sense of sacred space in the mosque, the extent of sense of sacred space in the three mosques varies. This feeling is higher in Imam Mosque (former Shah) than in the other specimen; the mosque of Tehran University is in the middle position compared to the other two samples and the al-Jawad mosque is in a completely different position, in terms of objectively and mentally signifying a sense of sacred space. Poorly evaluated, it is largely due to the modern, minimalist look that was taken into consideration when constructing the building. The study aimed to identify the sacred significant implications of sacred space in mosques and the factors that create the sacred space of the mosque in the mind of the audience. The results confirm that there is a significant relationship between the age of the attendees and the motivation to attend the mosque, and the absence of a significant relationship between the gender of the attendees and the motivation to attend the mosque show that the Imam Mosque has the best situation compared to the other two mosques. Among the reasons that show that Imam Mosque in Tehran is superior to other mosques in sense of sacred space, we can mention the following: Using four symmetrical porch pattern on four sides of yard with same dimensions along with other physical elements (courtyard, Dome, shrine, minaret, pulpit, and altar) in this mosque indicates the existence of objective indications of sacred space. Carefully considered in the Shabestan geometric system, this geometry is close to the square (on either side of the dome), which induces a sense of balance to the audience. The geometry of the dome is quite close to the square and the technique of turning the square into a circle, which is part of the mosque’s architecture, has been elaborately applied. In the meantime, all of the above is milder in the Tehran University Mosque, and in the Al-Jawad Mosque almost all of the above is not presented about the sense of sacred space.
Mahdi Hamzenejad, Amirmasood Nakhaee Sharif, Hanie Azizi Qomi,
Volume 5, Issue 1 (6-2020)
Abstract
According to Christine Norberg Schultz, the architectural identity of ancient cities splits itself into four cosmic, romantic, classical, and compound patterns. But does this view applies also to Iranian-Islamic cities? Schultz introduces genius loci of the space in Islamic cities in his classification of cosmic cities, but a quick look at the Islamic urban planning system reveals that this theory can be completely modified, at least in the geographical area of Iran. Do all Iranian cities possess a cosmic spirit? What is the model of Iranian cities according to the structural model of the theory of genius loci? Can the cultural and semantic dimensions of the environmental context proposed in this theory be accepted and generalized to Islamic environments? In this study, an attempt has been made to explore Iranian cities and pinpoint their urban model, and to localize this theory in Iran. The use of indigenous urban patterns in urban design is one of the valuable methods in this category that can help design and shape an identifiable city. Today, due to the spread of designs unrelated to the identity of cities and the disappearance of urban features, this identity is increasingly diminishing. The use of urban patterns is one of the useful methods in recovering this identity and characteristics. To this end, the present study, using qualitative interdisciplinary studies, phenomenology and library studies and considering climate, landscape and urban studies and the impact of psychology on these components, attempts to pin down the genius loci existing in Iranian-Islamic urban spaces, thus revising Schultz’s theory. Thus, Schultz’s point of view and the theory of genius loci are first examined. This study analyzes Iranian cities using this theory in four forms: romantic, cosmic, classical, and the composition of his choice. According to the typology of these cities, the studies are carried out from two perspectives: positional and semiotic, and in fact, the structure of Schultz’s theory has furnished a medium for defining the indigenous Islamic identity. The results show that all four of Schultz’s models can be defined in Iranian-Islamic cities, so that the character and genius loci of each city are shaped by such factors as climate, beliefs and culture, civilization and past urban planning. Northern cities and some western and northwestern cities with humid climates have the genius loci of romantic places, central cities with dry climates represent the genius loci of cosmic places and northern cities and some central and western cities reveal the genius loci of classical places.
The original idea of the City Garden in Western urban planning to create sustainable complexes was further linked to the environment in the 19th century. This plan in the Middle East contains a spiritual concept and was proposed in order to create an earthly paradise. Safavid Garden City, with its composite spirit, is a model for Iranian-Islamic cities as a utopia.
Mohammad Soltanzadeh,
Volume 5, Issue 1 (6-2020)
Abstract
The concept of social capital views the relationships and interactions of individuals, characterized by quality or quantity, as an asset, trying to use this asset to tackle problems in different areas. This concept is deemed a reliable measure, particularly in the residential neighborhoods context. This study discusses social capital in the form of a model for traditional communities of Iran and, by proposing indicators for social and built environment of the communities, explores their relationship with the components of social capital in the framework of a model of social capital, defined at community level and characterized by three cognitive, behavioral and psychological components. Social environment indicators include the administrative system (control and management, self-sufficiency) and the social composition, while the built environment indicators consist of diversity and function, composition and structure, architecture and design. Given the complexity of the concept of social capital and the fact that built environment does not directly create social capital, the study demonstrates that the control and management system of traditional communities is in accordance with the component of empowerment in the social capital model. On the other hand, the self-sufficiency of communities and their social composition affect the sense of community. In other words, social interactions increase by the consistency of demographic patterns and the self-sufficiency of communities, which means their ability to meet the daily and weekly needs of residents through their various functions. Along with the enhancement of social interactions, the sense of community is promoted and the component of neighboring among inhabitants is strengthened. Briefly, the social environment can affect the behavioral components of social capital (neighboring) in addition to its positive impact on both cognitive component of social capital (empowerment and sense of community). The built environment of communities possess a variety of components and functions. The diversity of functions led to the emergence of self-sufficient communities in terms of meeting the needs of inhabitants, while the function of components was beyond mere functional roles; they therefore sometimes played a social role (e.g. the mosque and neighborhood square) and provided a suitable basis for the active presence of residents at community level. In other words, the correct prediction of social needs of residents and appropriate responsiveness in the built environment provided the inhabitants with spaces necessary for their social activities at community level. On the other hand, the architecture and design of elements, precise prediction or embedment of components (frontispiece, hoods, etc.), selection of materials and creation of spatial qualities (dimensions, proportions, differences, etc.) are factors that increase social interactions and promote the residents’ sense of attachment to the community. At a higher level, the overall structure of community, composition of components, organization and location of functions such as house, passage and square are aimed to increase social interactions. Consequently, the built environment of communities specifically affect the sense of community (cognitive component), neighboring (behavioral component) and sense of attachment (psychological component) by: (1) increasing the level of social interaction, and (2) enhancing the sense of belonging to the community.
Somaye Jalali Milani, Ahad Nejadebrahimi, Hamed Beyti, Ali Vandshoari,
Volume 5, Issue 1 (6-2020)
Abstract
During the design process of a building facade, different individuals including client, architect, builder and even – indirectly – general public will either consciously or unconsciously impose parts of their attitudes, thoughts, beliefs and desires. In studies on the facades of historic buildings, understanding such thoughts and attitudes can lead the researcher to an analysis that transcends mere formal or stylistic investigations, and through studying the processes and factors affecting their designing and construction, provides a more comprehensive understanding of these facades, the quality of their formation and their relation to the context in which they have been built. Therefore, presuming the thoughts, wishes, attitudes and beliefs as a collection of conscious and unconscious mental concepts in humans’ minds, in this research the terms “thoughts” and “mentalities” have been considered respectively as conscious and unconscious mental concepts; and then attempts have been made to grasp the thoughts and mentalities of individuals or groups engaged in the formation of a historic house façade, through a case study relying on interpretive-historical research methodology. Thus, a Qajar structure named as Sorkheie House, located in the Sorkhab district of Tabriz and commissioned by Mehdikhan-e Asef-ol-saltaneh, was selected, trying to understand the thoughts and mentalities involved in the formation of a façade of the house which faces toward the outer courtyard. To this end, a brief overview on the two concepts o thoughts and mentalities was followed by examining the mentioned façade of the Sorkheie House and historical documents relating to the people involved in the design and construction processes of the house. Since of the people involved in the construction of the house, only the name of the owner (Asef-ol-saltaneh) is cited in the existing documents, at the first step, some historic texts from the Qajar period somehow pertaining to Asef-ol-Saltaneh or his political position were examined using content analysis method. Then at the second step, the façade of the house was read using iconological approach, relying on the information attained from previous step. According to this approach (which involved a methodology for reading the historic works of art and architecture in order to understand their hidden meanings), the details and ornaments of the facade were examined through iconographical analysis and iconological interpretation so as to pin down the thoughts and mentalities that had affected its design and construction. Finally, information attained from both steps were analyzed and discussed. Results of the research indicates that thoughts and mentalities of the people contributing to the designing process of a façade and its details are affected by their historical, economical and socio-cultural status. Moreover, the architect, builder or client, who are involved directly in the designing process, were influenced by general thoughts and mentalities of the society. The results also show that within the mentalities of the people involved in the designing of the facades of the Qajar houses, these facades represented an arena for the emergence of their implicit thoughts, desires and wishes, which was realized through applying patterns, ornaments, and details denoting such thoughts and wishes.
Nooshin Abbasi, Nima Valibeig, Nikta Arya,
Volume 6, Issue 1 (7-2021)
Abstract
The geometric proportion system in architectural monuments determines the consistency of the components of the building with the holistic building structure. In most architectural monuments, the geometric proportion of the structure is visible at the entrance of the building and is followed through the whole building. The current research is evaluating the renovation and comparing the emerged similarities and differences in the entrance spaces of the Abbasi Jame’ Mosque and Seyyed Jame’ Mosque in Isfahan. This evaluation is based on analyzing the geometric proportion system in the formation of the components and the dominating relations on the plan structure of the entrance spaces in these two buildings. The main thesis of this study is the similarity of the geometric elements and the plan proportion system of the mentioned mosques entrances. Proving these similarities, the geometric proportion plan of one building can be used as lead for conservation or renovation of the other building. The data collection and analysis method of this paper is based on library and field data collection and precise numerical and forming analysis. A comparative technique is used to measure the plan geometric proportion of the entrance spaces of the two Jame’ Mosques in Safavid (Abbasi Jamae’ Mosque) and Qajarid eras (Seyyed Jame’ Mosque in Isfahan). To analyze the samples, the current plan of both mosques was drawn with great details. Then, the plan of the entrance section was divided into different parts. Because most of the entrance spaces were quadrangular, the length and width dimensions of each part of the plan became apparent. Also, the diameter angle with the length of each space was determined. In the next step, Length-to-width ratios were measured in the plan of different sections of the entrance space of the samples. Then, the specified ratios were compared with the ratios of the proportional system of Iranian geometry and with this method, the basic shape of each space was determined. The use of a regular hexagonal base shape to arrange the entrance plan of the two mosques was distinguished, in the current plan of the entrance to the two Abbasi and Sayyid Jame’ Mosques in Isfahan. Spatial circulation was analyzed; moreover, the use of a similar geometric organization was identified in both Jame’ Mosques. However, the repeated organized ratio of the section of the entrance space plan in the samples was not detected. Therefore, based on the findings of the analysis and comparing them with each other, it could be understood that despite the similarity in appearance of the entrance space of the two buildings, there were significant differences in their spatial structure system. So the overall results of the study supported that the holistic structure of the two buildings follows the same rules of the Iranian geometric proportion system. Also, the results of the analysis highlighted the creative architectural skills are applied in the entrance space of both buildings.
Sabereh Leylasi Marand, Parisa Hashempour,
Volume 6, Issue 1 (7-2021)
Abstract
Physical individualization means a set of attributes and properties that create a special meaning for each space, what identifies the body are the same characteristics that make it different from others. The unique attributes and characteristics of each space that act together as a set, distinguish a body and distinguish it from others. The purpose of this study is to identify the factors affecting the physical identification of houses and to achieve the evolution of the physical identification of historic houses in the eighth district of Tabriz. At the beginning of the article, the definitions of individualization are stated from the perspectives of different thinkers, and then, according to the theoretical foundations, the components of physical individualization of houses are obtained to analyze a case study. Factors affecting physical identification can be divided into two categories of physical and human factors. In physical factors, using descriptive-analytical research method and based on Schultz theory, it was studied in three levels of exposure (typology, morphology, and topology). Based on the typology formed in an area of the eighth district of Tabriz, historical houses from the point of view of physical typology were classified into two main types of Qajar and first Pahlavi houses. Historical houses were studied according to the theoretical foundations of the research from the perspective of morphology and topology. Based on the findings, the distinguishing component of physical identification in the second type in terms of morphology (which includes the variety of openings and arches, variety of floor alignment, variety of decorations, details and materials used in interior and exterior and exterior views of the building and its architectural form) and spatial diversity, heat diversity and diversity of function and spatial arrangement of the components of topology have decreased compared to Qajar. The variety of light and the scale of the spaces were somewhat equal in the two species. The human component can be divided into two components: the architect and the residents or owners. Two internal and external factors affect an architect's work of art. Due to the lack of information about the architect and the inhabitants of historical houses, these two internal components cannot be examined and external factors affecting the architect, including the social, political and cultural conditions of the Qajar and first Pahlavi eras, have been examined. In the Qajar and first Pahlavi periods, due to the developments that took place in various political and cultural fields, major differences in values, thoughts, tendencies and methods of architecture and urban planning have emerged. This diversity is reflected in the architecture of residential buildings. The study of political and social developments of the Qajar and first Pahlavi periods of the study area in terms of external factors affecting the architect and residents, confirms the claim that in general the physical identification of Qajar historical houses in the eighth region of Tabriz is more transparent than the first Pahlavi houses in that area. It is more specific and the evolution of houses has shifted to simplicity.
Mahdieh Yaldayi, Mohsen Abbasi Herafteh,
Volume 6, Issue 1 (7-2021)
Abstract
Researchers require appropriate resources to conduct researches. In historical studies, data can be extracted only from these resources. Thus, in historical research especially in historical studies on architecture, the importance of these resources is doubled. Notwithstanding the resources of architectural historiography in Iran are very rare, since the architecture is considered as Container of life, it is almost not a resource that does not provide information about architecture. Therefore, this extent of resources makes identifying and organizing them to research in the history of Iranian architecture very rigorous. On the other hand, regarding the research of the history of Iranian architecture, researchers are faced with a wide range of unknown resources related to all aspects of human life, which makes risk of drowning in the ocean of information ahead. Thus, it seems to be necessary to identify and organize the resources of Historical Studies on Iranian Architecture. Recognizing the resources and understanding the dimensions, levels, species, and priorities for referring to them can reduce the time costing on the one hand and increase the validity of the data on the other hand. In this article, it has been tried to provide a clear view of the resources of historical studies of Iranian architecture. Based on the study of the background of the researches, the lack of theory, theoretical framework and conceptual model in this field was obvious and there were no coherent research results to identify the sources and discover the logical and hierarchical relationship between them from inductive strategy and specifically method. Therefore, the method of grounded theory was used to reach purpose of the research by focusing on the academic studies of the last four decades in the field of Iranian architectural studies. The discussion begins with what the resource is and definitions of it. Then, based on the literature on the subject of famous species of historical studies on Iranian architecture resources are introduced and then, based on the extracted codes, the species identified by this research are presented and completed. Depending on the type of expression, the time interval to the subject, the accuracy and the level of superficiality or depth of information and the degree of validity, several categories can be defined as the resource in the field of historical studies on Iranian architecture, which are generally dual. These dualities include; first- and second - hand resources, specialized and general resources, artistic and non-artistic resources, and explicit or implicit resources. In addition, there is a classification of resources in terms of the type of expression, which is also divided into two general categories of written and unwritten. By identifying and classifying these resources based on the mentioned method, a new formulation of the resources under the central concepts was done and finally three basic concepts for the types of the classified resources were introduced including: expression, time and depth of information. These three key concepts of expression, time and depth were identified as the basis for organizing the resources of historical studies on Iranian architecture and seven main types of them were introduced. These three concepts and seven categories include various levels and dimensions of resources and provide a proper tool for researchers to identify, categorize and prioritize in referring to the resources of historical studies on Iranian architecture.
Sajad Moazen, Reza Abouei,
Volume 6, Issue 2 (12-2021)
Abstract
The historical monuments of Iranian architecture are significantly alive and narrate the historical destiny of the Iranian nation. The utilization of metaphor to understand the spirit of place and referencing to the mystical literature of Iran determines the general framework in this article because spirituality is a vital aspect of the historic works of Iranian architecture. One of the most important reasons for writing this article is to study the unknown capacity of Iranian historical architectures to develop a correct interaction between humans and historical sites. The main purpose of this article is to provide a comprehensive definition of PIR as a concept beyond common knowledge and can be generalized to everything that has life and its adaptation to the historical monuments of Iranian architecture. John Ruskin says I want to highlight how the ineffable, unpresentable, sensual, heterogeneous possibilities of contemporary cities are particularly evident in their industrial ruins. Ruins may become spaces for leisure, adventure, cultivation, acquisition, shelter, and creativity. The greatest glory of a building is in its age, when we build; let us think that we build forever. Let it not be for present delight, nor present use alone; let it be such work as our descendants will thank us for, and let us think, as we lay stone on stone, that a time is to come when those stones will be held sacred because our hands have touched them. Indeed, the greatest glory of a building is not in its stones, nor its gold. Its glory is in its age, and the deep sense of voicefulness, of stern watching, of mysterious sympathy, nay, even of approval condemnation, which we feel in walls that have long been washed by the passing waves of humanity. Buildings achieve such voicefulness from the succeeding generations that use them. One thing we cannot do with the past is replicate it. Then, this definition is compared with old architectures of Iran, and, using a phenomenological method, the applications of “PIR” in Persian literature have been investigated. In the following article, the adaptability of this understanding from PIR was investigated with architectural heritage and with a comparative method; the possible similarities between these two themes were proved. Aging is defined by passing time quantitatively. However, the “PIR” formation concept is based on the passing time with specific conditions. Imparting the human to serenity and spiritual felicity is the most significant duty of the “PIR” or Perfect Human that is achieved by referring to archetype. The “old wise man” introduced by Jung is perfectly similar to the “PIR” Iranian concept. In his philosophy, the archetype is originated from the collective unconscious of the person, a pronoun that is containing several thousands of human experiences and archetype pictures. Since PIR is a formed picture of active wise and described as a holly person in the heavenly realm in Sohrevardi epistles, this similarity emerged. As a conclusion of this paper, the spirit of place in Iranian historical architectures contains a kind of life that is a gift from the ancient wisdom of humans. As a result, Iranian historic architecture can play its role as a PIR in society, and their nature changes from a museum to a relaxing and educating place.